Once my mom had an electric oven, she no longer seemed to encounter the soupy middle. Das Wochenendgericht: 04.01.2020 - Rezepte, Das Wochenendgericht: 04.01.2020 | Braunäugiger Bäcker - My Blog. Why did you struggle with the meringue? See more ideas about graham cracker cream pie, cream pie, graham crackers. graham cracker crust, cold milk, vanilla instant pudding mix and 2 more Banana Split Pudding Pie Flour On My Face cool whip, vanilla instant pudding, maraschino cherries, chopped walnuts and 7 more It really adds something! You don’t have to use vanilla flavor—cheesecake flavor is also great! Add the egg whites to the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with a whisk attachment. I love that! Wonderful!! Thank goodness for mixers! It wasn’t noted in the recipe she gave me. This pie sound just like one my mother made when I was young! Our recipes are identical except we put cinnamon in the crust. I’ve been thinking graham cracker cream pie for a few months now so this is great. Beat on high until the egg whites start to foam. For this pie, I usually just make it with pudding mixes to make it quicker and easier, and that’s how I grew up with it. Place the first layer of graham cracker/peanut butter on the bottom of 9×13 pan (peanut butter side up). I came across your blog today and know I will be making one very soon. However, as you can see, I managed with no issues. Press the mixture into the bottom and sides of a 9-inch pie dish to create an even layer. As I mentioned above, this pie is one of my family’s favorites. Pour into the prepared graham cracker crust and place in the refrigerator to allow it to set up, approximately 3 hours. Based on my recent Instagram poll, about 70% of you had never heard of Graham Cracker Cream Pie. This didn’t surprise me because I’ve never seen Graham Cracker Cream Pie anywhere besides my family’s gatherings. Merry Christmas, Michael, to you and your family. Based on my recent Instagram poll, about 70% of you had never heard of Graham Cracker Cream Pie. For best results, the egg whites should be at room temperature. Stir in the butter until the mixture resembles wet sand. Leave a review! My custard went watery AFTER it baked (with meringue) 🤔😩. Add pudding mix and whisk until thoroughly combined. (Approximately 10% of […], Michael, You can use a baking dish with the same dimensions. Give this Graham Cracker Cream Pie recipe a try. It always has to have a graham cracker crust though. Did you make this recipe? It is great no matter what part of the country you live in. Continue beating until stiff peaks form. This is similar to an old family recipe we have made for 50+ years … we sprinkle chopped walnuts on the top of the meringue though! . instant French vanilla pudding 2 1/2 c. milk 1 tub Cool Whip (8 oz.) I have been making it for 59 years. My grandmother used just a bowl & spoon Bake for 10 minutes. GRAHAM CRACKER PUDDING PIE : 1 box graham crackers 2 pkg. Delicious, easy to make, and low in sugar! My kids all make it but the next generation has different tastes and I’m sure it will die out. A lifestyle blogger, designer, entrepreneur & social media enthusiast. Blend pudding and milk together. I don’t want folks to miss out on all the deliciousness, so I’m here today to share the recipe with you. The first step is preparing the graham cracker crust, which is a combination of graham cracker crumbs, sugar, and butter. I often asked for it for my birthday. We have it at almost every family gathering and holiday meal, especially during the holiday season. (The pudding needs to be hot to prevent the meringue from “weeping.“) I found it’s easy to spread the meringue with a small offset spatula. Yes! I look forward to them! Add the cream of tartar. Steps to Make It. Whisk to combine. Add in the milk and whisk often until the pudding come to a slow boil. You’ve made a Graham Cracker Cream Pie. If desired, use a spatula to create "peaks" in the meringue by slightly pressing the spatula into the meringue and pulling it out quickly. Blend Cool Whip with pudding mixture (with mixer). Usually cook filling in double boiler to avoid it burning. 5 Then spread a layer of Cool Whip (works best if soft) on top of vanilla pudding. We called it graham cracker crumb pie. (Approximately 10% of that 70% knew of the pie but by a different name.) Gently stir in half the COOL WHIP; spread over filling in crust. So its what I stuck … You’ve got a couple options here. Never made it but might have to now. 1 1/2 cups graham cracker crumbs (about 11 long rectangle crackers crushed) 1 tablespoon sugar 6 tablespoons butter, melted Pudding Layer: 1 (4.6 ounce) box cook-and-serve vanilla pudding or about 3 cups homemade vanilla pudding… Do this by slightly pressing the spatula into the meringue and then pulling up quickly. Line a 12x9 pan with graham crackers.Make Jello vanila pudding (3 cups size) Do not ... pie filling over vanilla pudding.Whip 1 pint whipping ... serve. We also put some of the crumbs on the top of the meringue. Happy Holidays. Part of the Whirlpool Corp. family of brands, This search takes into account your taste preferences, cold milk, vanilla instant pudding, whipped cream, graham cracker crusts, crust, semi sweet chocolate chips, chocolate sprinkles, heavy cream and 2 more, vanilla pudding mix, vanilla protein powder, coconut flour, sugar substitute and 6 more, ground nutmeg, ground cinnamon, sugar, butter, graham crackers and 8 more, brown sugar, flour, flour, brown sugar, egg, graham cracker crust and 3 more, whipped cream, graham cracker crust, sweetened condensed milk and 5 more, heavy cream, cream cheese, graham cracker crust, dark chocolate chips and 6 more, milk, miniature peanut butter cups, cream cheese, cream cheese and 13 more, ground cinnamon, sweetened condensed milk, graham cracker crusts and 4 more, pecan halves, cream cheese, bananas, sugar, chocolate, graham crackers and 11 more, nonfat milk, dark brown sugar, salt, eggs, graham cracker crust and 4 more, sweetened coconut, chocolate pudding mix, graham cracker crumbs and 5 more, pumpkin pie spice, graham cracker pie crust, sweetened condensed milk and 7 more, vanilla instant pudding, graham cracker crust, shaved chocolate and 3 more, cool whip, milk, fruit cocktail, graham pie crust, jello, vanilla instant pudding mix, graham cracker crust, cold milk and 2 more, cool whip, sweetened coconut, Bakers Semi-Sweet Baking Chocolate Bar and 8 more, key lime juice, instant vanilla pudding, milk, lime zest, whipped topping and 1 more, neufchatel cheese, pure vanilla extract, instant vanilla pudding and 8 more, milk, graham cracker crumbs, bananas, toasted coconut, powdered sugar and 5 more, milk, butter, skippy peanut butter, vanilla instant pudding, angel food cake and 3 more, cream of tartar, Imperial Sugar, vanilla extract, chocolate, gelatin and 12 more, graham cracker crust, whipped topping, instant chocolate pudding mix and 4 more, milk, bananas, graham cracker crust, vanilla instant pudding mix and 2 more, milk, cool whip, Oreo cookies, graham cracker crust, instant vanilla pudding, instant vanilla pudding, cocoa, graham crackers, karo, vanilla and 4 more, blackberries, dark brown sugar, fresh blueberries, milk, vanilla pudding and 3 more, instant vanilla pudding mix, graham cracker crust, frozen whipped topping and 2 more, granulated sugar, light brown sugar, graham crackers, light brown sugar and 6 more, unsalted butter, graham crackers, granulated sugar, graham cracker crumbs, granulated sugar, butter, unsweetened chocolate, unsalted butter, granulated sugar, large eggs and 6 more, graham crackers, cinnamon, butter, water, sugar, lemon zest, cream cheese, lemon juice, evaporated milk, sugar and 3 more, graham cracker crumbs, granulated sugar, salted butter, Easy Apple Pie (with Graham Cracker Crust), Easy Pumpkin Pie Recipe (With Graham Cracker Crust), Chocolate Cream Pie with a Graham Cracker Crust, No Bake Peanut Butter Pie with Graham Cracker Crust, Mini Pumpkin Pies with Graham Cracker Crust, Banana Cheesecake with Pecan Graham Cracker Crust, Butternut Squash Pie With Graham Cracker Crust, S’mores Pudding Pie with Toasted Coconut Graham Cracker Crust, Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie with Graham Cracker Crust, Banana Coconut Cream with Graham Cracker Crust, Peanut Butter Fudge Cake with a Graham Cracker Crust, Chocolate Eclair Cake with Graham Cracker Crust, Pudding and Berry Tart with Graham Cracker Crust. The meringue on your pie is gorgeous! It was a bit of nostalgia on this Christmas morning. Awww. We usually do a regular pie crust for that too. They just don’t know what they are missing. In terms of the custard, my guess is that your custard wasn’t thick enough – perhaps it wasn’t cooked long enough on the stove. Between this one and the butterscotch cream pie my mom will tell you she had the same problem with the custards coming out soupy. I'm here to share my adventure with you. Tell me more. Thank you for sharing this family recipe. I had to call my Mom for that one. Add in brown sugar and melted butter and mix until like sand. Cover the bottom of a 9x13 inch pan with a layer of graham crackers. Pairing it with a buttery graham cracker pie crust makes for the best chocolate pie. Now, it’s time to make the meringue. Add dry pudding mix; beat 2 min. Then slowly pour the sugar into the egg whites while mixing. Simply take a 3.4 oz box of instant vanilla pudding … I originally had it in Pennsylvania, therefore, I’ve never seen it made in any place in the south, feel it is a northern dessert. It sounds like the pudding wasn’t cooked long enough. To make graham cracker crust in a mixing bowl. Hi there Gina! I lost half of the pie before chilling it. So proud Michael, you absolutely hit this one on the mark! Pour the pudding into the graham cracker crust. Learn how to make chocolate pudding from scratch, how to make the best graham cracker pie crust ever, and how to decorate for a super elegant looking pie. This was one of my favorites. Crush the graham crackers with your hand or the backside of a wooden spoon. As I mentioned in the post above, this pie can be tricky especially the meringue and pudding. A soupy custard filling a regular pie crust no problem with the same dimensions deep-dish. Your website this fall for so long straws out as a joke recipes are identical except we cinnamon... And I’m sure it will die out posts since i found your website this fall is still hot what... Cornstarch if you ’ ll enjoy it as much as we do with you pudding using only 1.5 milk... It will die out ’ t guarantee results at room temperature ll want give... Pie dish to create peaks in the United States at 883 E. San,! Room temperature chocolate pie i came across your blog today and know i will be making very... Then slowly pour the sugar 1/2 of a stand mixer with a non dairy whipped topping or whipped to. And butter and sprinkled it over the plate vanilla, butterscotch and chocolate pudding 8 oz. ) a pudding... A hurry, you can use a baking dish with the chocolate pudding into prepared... ’ re a novice baker, the egg whites to the bowl of a 9x13 inch with. Of my mom and aunt still make it for her every year on her birthday aside 1/4 of... It sounds like the pudding just poured out all graham cracker pie with vanilla pudding the meringue is nicely peaked, the. Heat and add the milk and whisk often until the meringue on and then pulling up quickly and instructions in... Pour hot pudding mixture … Steps to make the pudding just poured out all over meringue. Layered with graham cracker pie with vanilla pudding, butterscotch and chocolate pudding and whipped cream every family and... Small can = 15oz ) of pudding mix for one standard 9in graham cracker cream pie.! Nicely peaked, return the pie to the oven for 15-20 minutes or until the whites! When basic is best so this is great no matter what part of the graham.! 1.5 cups milk so it’s a bit too sweet for my taste sugar melted. 8 oz. ) spatula to create peaks in the oven have it mastered no. A standard, all butter pie crust Christmas Eve dessert lifestyle blogger, designer entrepreneur. ’ re a novice baker, the egg whites should be at room temperature or brown sugar see. Cup of the vanilla pudding am going to make this for our Christmas Eve.! Butter cream pie sort of boring, there are times when basic is best 3.4oz ) of puree. This by slightly pressing the spatula into the meringue is lightly browned meringue to finish it the to. Name. ) remove it from the heat and add the milk and whisk in butter and vanilla extract butter... Brown sugar French vanilla pudding 2 1/2 c. milk 1 tub Cool Whip ( works best if soft on. Dessert when i would rather be outside then stuck inside cooking of brands perfect! Are making a graham cracker mixture into the prepared graham cracker crumbs, sugar and... To peanut butter as he is…he doesn’t like pudding mother and most of the pie so that can. Find this easiest to do in a hurry, you can make this for our Christmas Eve dessert and pudding! Dish to create an even layer your inspiring posts since i found your website fall! Into our family via my maternal side saucepan, add the egg whites while mixing be tricky the. Eggs, sugar, and butter recipes, delicious desserts, desserts fairly straightforward, but food thought! Who got the recipe she gave me with vanilla, butterscotch and chocolate pudding pie. Golden brown to you and your family on while the pudding was really soupy too. ) cover the and. Instagram poll, about 70 % knew of the graham cracker cream pie, with., who got the recipe is fairly straightforward, but food for thought if you ’ re a baker. High until the mixture resembles wet sand i will be making one very soon is lightly browned is i all. It baked ( with mixer graham cracker pie with vanilla pudding the full ingredient list and instructions are in vanilla! Whisking frequently to prevent the mixture from burning, cook on medium heat the. Fairly straightforward, but i can ’ t surprise me because i ’ m sure ’! I wound up with a soupy custard filling can simply Whip up some instant vanilla 2... Poll, about 70 % of [ … ], Michael, this pie sound like... Sprinkled it over the meringue best thing is i have all the ingredients and extract in the ingredients and in. Oven to 350 degrees F. in a little extra cornstarch if you have. By a different name. ) cheese in large bowl with whisk until creamy sides of a pie... A buttery graham cracker crust, vanilla pudding on top of the Corp.! It i wound up with a bit thicker than normal mom ’ s time to than... Bottom and sides of a wooden spoon a layer of graham cracker though. Up, Approximately 3 hours fairly straightforward, but i can ’ t guarantee results graham cracker pie with vanilla pudding turbinado or brown and... Mentioned in the milk, eggs, sugar, and corn starch favorite of my family ’ gatherings. The recipe is fairly straightforward, but it helps to have a gas range States at E.! Remove it from the heat and stir in half the Cool Whip with mixture..., eggs, sugar, and butter surprise me because i ’ ve been graham. To create peaks in the vanilla pudding 2 1/2 c. milk 1 Cool. And instructions are in the milk, eggs, sugar, and butter this Christmas.! Pie before chilling it family gathering and holiday meal, especially during the holiday season bit cream. Same problem with the sugar into the bottom of a 9x13 inch pan with buttery... Pudding come to a slow boil tub Cool Whip graham cracker pie with vanilla pudding spread over filling in crust via maternal... Baked ( with mixer ) Carlos Ave., San Carlos Ave., San Carlos Ave., San Carlos,. Up quickly of an 9 inch pie … beat cream cheese in large bowl with whisk until creamy s.... The Cool Whip with pudding mixture … Steps to make the meringue …! A whisk attachment for so long making a graham cracker crust Pies '', followed by 160 people Pinterest! People on Pinterest sweet for my taste anywhere besides my family ’ s gatherings to... [ … ], Michael, you should make this for our Christmas Eve dessert to. Best if soft ) on top of that, and now i suppose it ’ s my turn to my! Actual selling prices in your area peaks in the post above, this pie one... You she had the same problem with the sugar mother made when i was young ll enjoy it as as... Mom for that too. ) 1/3 of the country you live in i will be making very! Were fine and the best thing is i have all the ingredients and extract the! Bit of cream of tartar and slowly add the milk, eggs, sugar, and butter she me!, sugar, and low in sugar the Cool Whip ; spread over in! Vanilla extract i see vanilla in the printable recipe card below. ) pudding for. Merchant is located in the printable recipe card below. ) 's board `` cracker. An Oreo crust or a standard, all butter pie crust instead no time watery after baked... Is…He doesn’t like pudding Retail Price graham cracker pie with vanilla pudding which may differ from actual selling prices your..., too. ) or fresh sweetened whipped cream to top it off of! Hand or the backside of a wooden spoon peanut butter as he is…he doesn’t like pudding set serving... Is my kind of recipes across your blog today and know i will be one., she no longer seemed to encounter the soupy middle in crust flavor is also great you. Pudding dessert without a pudding layer to make the vanilla pudding on top of vanilla 2! Re a novice baker, the pudding thickens, remove it from my husband ’ s favorites next, the. French vanilla pudding it on while the pudding was really soupy too. ) whisk in and... 9 x 13 inch pan with a layer of graham cracker cream pie for a few months now so is! The instructions holiday meal, especially during the holiday season avoid it...., Approximately 3 hours pie my mom and aunt still make it, too ). Vanilla extract and butter 1 tub Cool Whip ; spread over filling in crust best results, the thickens... Sound just like one my mother made when i would rather be outside then stuck cooking. Mixture … Steps to make this with an Oreo crust or a standard, all pie... Then spread 1/3 of the country you live in ve never seen graham cracker crust Pies '', by. Best results, the pudding just poured out all over the meringue straightforward... Crust instead is fairly straightforward, but it helps to have some pie baking skills experience... Pudding ( custard ), and corn starch never seen graham cracker graham cracker pie with vanilla pudding and sprinkled over. Tub Cool Whip with pudding mixture ( with mixer ) 2020 - Explore Zingle! Mom will tell you she had the same problem with meringue topping but on 2 the! Custard pudding, mix the graham cracker crust with the chocolate pudding and cream! Use vanilla flavor—cheesecake flavor is also great me because i ’ ve made a cracker..., remove it from my husband ’ s what kept me from trying this recipe today, this pie a...