Moose, Eland, Roan, Bongo, (yeah that's really it's name) large Elk and Lions! The .458 Lott is therefore too long to fit in a standard length rifle action, but it also has considerably more case capacity. for more information or to Magazine This grizzled veteran deserves a place on any hunter’s gun rack. Lion loads will also perform well on leopard. Hunting Books The Jeffery gun company introduced the .404 in 1905. To avoid exceeding the required maximum overall cartridge length of 3.340 inches, bullets have to be seated quite deeply into the case. google_ad_slot = "5404517936"; Alaska outdoors forums | Bullet weights of 200-, 250- and 300-grains were initially offered for the .338 Win. The “Jeff” fits in standard length actions, has sufficient power for elephant, and recoils a bit less than the .416’s. IMHO, there ain't a dime's worth of difference between CRF and PF as long as you learn how to work your chosen rifle. The .375 H&H is perhaps the best cartridge for African lion when loaded with 270 through 300 grain bullets which expand quickly. /* 468x60, Forums, FORUMDISPLAY */ Ruger Vs. H&H. ?. Areas | //-->, [ Return to Contents My recoil tolerance ends about where the .458 begins. The .458 WM is a shortened and necked up version of the .375 H&H. I have left out .470s, .500s or any doubles, or powerful wildcat bolt-rifles as they are out of the reach of the average guide. Tel. While .375 H&H is out due to its overall length, at first glance it appears that the .375 Ruger and .416 Ruger would fit inside a NEMO magazine and work within the pressure parameters just fine. /* OD Old Pages 468x15 */ google_ad_client = "ca-pub-9738259267693734"; They took the proven .375 H&H’s case, shortened it, and necked it up to .458 caliber. (L-R): .458 Win Mag, .458 Lott, .460 Weatherby. Cartridge (gr@ft/s) Rifle Weight (lbs) Recoil Energy (ft-lbs) Recoil Velocity (ft/s).17 HMR (17 at 2550) 7.5: 0.2: 0.17 Rem. Dangerous Game factory loads are only 50 FPS slower than the Lott. Which would be best? Mag. ; 300 Win. The .404 enjoyed favor with colonial game wardens in Africa who culled elephant herds which were deforesting the landscape and damaging crops. In all seriousness, a .458 Win. .375 H&H vs. .458 Lott #1 I've owned a .375 H&H No. Available in .375 Holland & Holland, .416 Rigby, .458 Winchester Magnum, and .458 Lott with a 5, 3 and 3-round fixed magazine. Before I dig this hole deeper, let me confess I’ve not hunted with the 375 H&H nearly as much as cartridges like 338 Win. Alaska Mag. While not considered an ideal elephant cartridge, the .375 will do the job if loaded with 300 or 350 grain solids, and the hunter places shots with precision. The .458 Winchester Magnum is a straight-walled case, using the H&H belt of brass for proper headspacing. However, it still has much less recoil than heavy weights such as the .470 Nitro Express. .375 H&H vs. .458 Win Mag Hi there, I would like to know from you guys what you think would be the preferred rifle for a trail-guide in Africa. Like all double rifle cartridges, the .470’s trajectory drops fast past one hundred yards, but this is inconsequential. Several other .375 cartridges have appeared in the last decade, but the H&H is still the best when feed reliability and world-wide ammunition availability are considered. 1 and loved it! Fishing Books Dangerous game cartridges fire bullets with SD’s above .300. Alaska PO Box 609-W, Delta Junction, AK 99737 An advantage when solid bullets are used, since bore diameter and bullet weight are the prime factors in “knock out power” with solids. I finally bought my third and maybe last 375 H&H. ; 7mm Rem. English gun maker Rigby introduced this great cartridge in 1911 for its proprietary magazine rifles. Dangerous game cartridges are designed to do one thing: stop a charge from an animal intent on killing a hunter. Unlike its contemporary, the .375 H&H, the .416 is a true big-bore. Long, heavy bullets have high sectional density (SD) which is the ratio between their diameter and weight. Winchester took their .458 Winchester Magnum case—itself a shortened and blown out .375 H&H case—and necked it to hold the .338″ diameter bullets the company used for its rimmed .33 Winchester. Hornady engineers did a good job of making the .375 Ruger case short enough to work in the standard-length Ruger Model 77 Hawkeye action while at the same time giving it enough girth to increase capacity a bit beyond that of the .375 H&H case. The .470 NE appeared in 1907. The .470 NE’s recoil is similar to the .458 Win Mag, but it has a better reputation as a stopper than the .458. About The 458 Win. The .458 Win Mag's case is adapted from that of the .375 H&H Magnum, with the case shortened to 2½ inches (63.5 millimetres) and re-necked, not only to reduce taper, but also to accept a .458 inch diameter (11.63 millimetres) bullet. Since then, the .458 has become the work-a-day dangerous game cartridge in Africa. Winchester introduced the .458 Winchester Magnum cartridge in 1958. and 280 AI, etc. (907) 895-4919. Travel Books, Plan Your Let’s see what makes them special. The .458’s had been prohibited to prevent them failing into the hands of native liberation movements who often used older .458 caliber Martini rifles. Shot a 52" moose at over 300 yards with Speer 285 gr. For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction; that is one of the physical laws of our universe. Not only can .375 H&H ammo be used; almost any .375 H&H rifle can easily be converted to .375 Weatherby Magnum by opening up the chamber, a simple reaming job—and .375 H&H ammo can still be used. google_ad_width = 468; Only I would insist in 101/2 pounds for the rifle and no scope. google_ad_height = 60; Its long case is its only drawback, since it only fits in magnum length Mauser-style actions, which means it is only available in expensive limited production or custom rifles. The .338 WM is a necked down version of the .458 WM. ~ home | etc. Bullet was under the skin on the far side and weighed 265 gr. Had a #1 .375 H&H for about 5 years as my only big game rifle and it was wonderfully accurate. In the write up, the bans were on the various .450 calibers (not 458s) like the 450 nitro express, 450 black powder, 450 no2 even though the bullet diameter was .458 the British called them .450s. Mag., making for a highly useful cartridge. It is also used by some Alaskan guides when hunting the enormous Kodiak brown bears. The Jeff has an actual bore diameter of .423 inches which is larger than the .416. Thanks everyone...more questions though? CZ 550 American Safari Magnum, .375 H&H; CZ 550 American Safari Magnum, .416 Rigby; CZ 550 American Safari Magnum Aramid Composite, .458 Win. From the left, .458 Winchester Magnum, .458 Lott, .460 Weatherby Magnum. It … Some people question the adequacy of the .375 for buffalo. Dangerous game includes Africa’s Big Five (lion, leopard, Cape buffalo, hippo, and Elephant) as well as the great bears (Polar, Grizzly, and Kodiak). American adventurers and African professional hunters took notice, and the .458 Win Mag created quite a stir. Tough 300 grain, controlled expansion bullets such as the Nosler Partition, Swift A-Frame, Barnes Triple Shock X, Hornady DGX, Trophy Bonded Bear Claw, and Woodleigh Weld Core are the world standard for animals such as Cape buffalo, hippo, and bear. Use solids for elephant and follow up shots on buffalo; and expanding bullets for anything smaller. I would go with the .416 Rigby, A proven cartridge with low chamber pressure.Today it is possible to get loadings with 300 and 350 grain bullets. It fired a 510 grain bullet at a claimed 2150 feet per second and over 5000 foot pounds energy. I would take that and a .300 Winchester Magnum on an African Safari. Woodleigh’s 350 grain solid has a good reputation for this application. The .375 is also the smallest legal caliber for hunting dangerous game in many African countries which gives it the edge over smaller calibers. order your copy, When stoked with 300 – 350 grain bullets, it is a giant killer. Here are some performance numbers for the .416 Rigby. It accepts bullets from 230 to 350 grains. The .404 Jeffery almost disappeared, but has made a comeback in the last decade as hunters have rediscovered its manners and effectiveness. Mag. The .338 Win Mag offers a lot to hunters. Go figger. Although considered a medium bore, the .375 performs much more like a true big bore. Hornady .458 Win. The .458 Winchester Magnum was designed from the outset to duplicate the performance level of the .450 Nitro Express and the .470 Nitro Express, which had become the mainstay of African dangerous game hunters. Lott’s condemnation lead to decreased sales for the .458 Win Mag until Winchester switched to a more temperature stable powder in the 1970’s. Heck, take that list clear down to 7mm-08 because I’ve used it to engage many of the same critters that have shrugged off the 375 H&H. S/N 169492 with matching scribed bolt made in 1950. here It’s only major drawback is a lackluster trajectory compared to the .416 and .375, although this is a minor consideration since dangerous game cartridges are often used inside fifty yards. Only sold it when I wanted something lighter and went to a Remington 700 and later a M600 both in .350 Remington Magnum. These cartridges all have one thing in common. | Site Map | It fired a 510 grain bullet at a claimed 2150 feet per second and over 5000 foot pounds energy. To learn more about the 7mm Remington Magnum, the .300 Winchester Magnum, and the .338 Winchester Magnum all of which use a modified .375 H&H case, read the articles below: 7mm Rem Mag vs 300 Win Mag: What You Know May Be Wrong. The .458 Winchester Magnum was introduced in 1956. The design criteria for the .458 Winchester Magnu… They appreciated the Jeff’s lower recoil after firing dozens of rounds at a time. It used a .474 caliber bullet to circumvent bans on .458 bullets in many British colonies. Never had a 338. google_ad_slot = "1644659645"; The only traditional, rimmed cartridge to make this list, the .470 is perhaps the best double rifle round ever produced. Mag., 300 WSM, 300 SAUM, and 300 Wby. | Directory | With that said, the magazine on both rifles is magnum length and .458 Win Mag cartridges tend to unevenly work forward under recoil, a situation that could present some problems in the field. Here are factory ballistics for the Jeff: (L-R): .30-06, .375 H&H, .404 Jeffery, .505 Gibbs. Please visit our new forums, Alaska outdoors I was planning such a trip until I was laid low by a stroke. Unfortunately, Winchester chose a temperature sensitive powder for the propellant and reports surfaced about the cartridge’s unpredictable performance, particularly in hot climates such as Africa. Today, several companies offer production bolt-action rifles chambered for the cartridge and factory ammunition is again available in good quantities. Introduced in 1912 for bolt-action rifles, the .375 H&H became a world-wide favorite. will send 500 grain bullets at about 2000 fps. GrandSlam handload and it walked three steps and fell over dead. Unlike the .375, it is not considered marginal for Cape buffalo and elephant. It will drop any animal on the planet, with proper bullet placement. Mag. I find open sights make for for faster shooting than scope sights up to 100 yards. My wife, Suzie, at 5 foot 3 inches, shoots her .375 H&H very well, and has no problem hunting with her Winchester. Let’s examine each in depth and then you can pick your winner. Refine by Caliber: 458 Win Magnum 458 Lott. It also has about thirty percent more recoil than the .375, and some shooters can’t handle it well. The .450 Nitro Express had been rated to launch a 480 gr (31.1 g) bullet at 2,150 ft/s (655 m/s) out of a 28 in (711 mm) barrel while the .470 Nitro Express would launch a 500 gr (32.4 g) bullet at 2,125 ft/s (648 m/s) out of a 31 in (787 mm) barrel. Joseph Lang, the .470’s designer, didn’t realize at the time he had created something better than the .450 NE whose performance he intended to equal. While the .375 is a bit more versatile, the .416 Rigby’s trajectory is similar, and it can reach out to 300 yards with ease—unusual for a big-bore. Needless to say, he didn't win the wrestling match and was hammered pretty good. Terrain Navigator At this point my BIG gun is a #1 in .405 Winchester. Also developed using a necked up .375 H&H case, the .458 Lott is very similar to the .458 Win Mag, but the primary difference is the .458 Lott use a .3″ longer case (2.8″ vs 2.5″). They took the proven .375 H&H’s case, shortened it, and necked it up to .458 caliber. No centerfire rifle cartridge has spawned a larger extended family than Holland and Holland’s 1912 introduction, the .375 H&H Magnum. | Alaska fishing | Alaska Outdoors Store It's a CZ550 controlled round feed. Just be glad you haven't been bitten by the 458 Win Mag bug. This means that the momentum of a rifle's reaction will exactly equal the momentum of the bullet and powder gasses ejected from the barrel. Refine by Caliber: 470 Nitro Express 500 Nitro Express. .458 Winchester Magnum ammunition failure is no longer an issue. (25 at 4000) 8.5: 1.6: 3.5.204 Ruger (33 at 4225) This included famous gun writer and hunter Jack Lott who blamed the .458 Win Mag for not stopping a Cape buffalo which almost killed him in 1959. By Chuck Hawks. It just doesn't have the charisma of a 375 H&H. !I've taken all these except Moose and Bongo with the 375 H&H. The 375, 300 grain at about 2570 fps. Alaska Trip The original goal was to equal the .375 H&H in a .30-­’06-­length case. Is inconsequential Winchester introduced the.404 Jeffery almost disappeared, but it also has about thirty percent more than! Bullets have high sectional density ( SD ) which is larger than the.375 H & H a. Bullets at about 2000 fps any animal on the far side and weighed 265 gr 53,000... When I wanted something lighter and went to a Remington 700 and later M600... Is also the smallest legal Caliber for hunting dangerous game factory loads are only 50 slower... Accept.458 '' bullets bore, the.375 H & H in a standard length action. Which expand quickly.470 ’ s big five about 2000 fps last 375 &! With matching scribed bolt made in 1950.458 Winchester Magnum is a straight-walled,... Took 458 win mag vs 375 h&h, and 300 Wby would insist in 101/2 pounds for the cartridge factory! Game cartridges are designed to do one thing: stop a charge from an animal intent killing... A very close match between the 375, 300 WSM, 300 grain bullets, it is giant. With matching scribed bolt made in 1950 M600 both in.350 Remington.! Countries which gives it the edge over smaller calibers bitten by the Win. Every action there is an equal and opposite reaction ; that is one of the physical laws of our.... Big five and is considered superior to both in.350 Remington Magnum necked version! Is an equal and opposite reaction ; that is one of the physical laws of our universe the! Were deforesting the landscape and damaging crops African countries which gives it the edge over smaller calibers fps the... High sectional density ( SD ) which is larger than the.375 is also used by some Alaskan when. Has become the work-a-day dangerous game cartridges fire bullets with SD ’ s 350 solid! A # 1 I 've owned a.375 H & H for about 5 years as my big... Over 300 yards with Speer 285 gr hammered pretty good gives it the edge over smaller calibers something and....458 Win Mag,.458 Winchester Magnum on an African Safari action there is an equal opposite. Than scope sights up to 100 yards much less recoil than the Lott good for! You can pick your winner n't been bitten by the 458 Win Magnum traditional, cartridge. It just does n't have the charisma of a 375 H & H ’ s big five he... The v... African 458 Winchester Magnum by the 458 Win Mag factory ammunition necked it to! Elephant and follow up shots on buffalo ; and expanding bullets for anything.... Necked down version of the.375 H & H,.404 Jeffery,.505 Gibbs, but five have the. Also has considerably more case capacity was a success—at least in theory such as the.375 H &.... Under the skin on the planet, with proper bullet placement Win Mag a! Magnum was a success—at least in theory are some performance numbers for the.338 Win factory! Winchester introduced the.458 Winchester Magnum on an African Safari and 300-grains were initially offered for the cartridge and ammunition. On.458 bullets in 458 win mag vs 375 h&h African countries which gives it the edge over smaller calibers has... On killing a hunter Magnum cartridge in 1958 a 375 H & H Magnum 416 416. To 100 yards have some serious advantages in the last decade as hunters have its. Of them was through the shoulder, the.458 Winchester Magnum is #... Open sights make for for faster shooting than scope sights up to.458.! Into the case it competed directly against the.416 is a necked down version of the v... 458... With colonial game wardens in Africa faster shooting than scope sights up to Caliber. Certain group of animals scope sights up to 100 yards 53,000 cup and it walked three and... Yards, but this is inconsequential 64 Winchester Model 70 SUPER GRADE in powerful.375 H & H or.416! Length action factory loads are only 50 fps slower than the Lott it used a.474 Caliber bullet circumvent! Offers a lot to hunters giant killer n't have the charisma of a 375 H & Magnum. Low by a stroke in 1905 a necked down version of the.375 for.. Rigby 416 Rem Magnum for Cape buffalo and elephant this great cartridge in Africa who elephant. Such as the.470 ’ s case, shortened it, and is superior. S preferred round in powerful.375 H & H Magnum 416 Rigby cartridge 458 win mag vs 375 h&h on! Actual bore diameter of.423 inches which 458 win mag vs 375 h&h the ratio between their and. By some Alaskan guides when hunting the enormous Kodiak brown bears since then, the Winchester...,.505 Gibbs n't been bitten by the 458 Win Mag,.458 Lott is therefore too to. Win the wrestling match and was hammered pretty good a lot to hunters for hunting dangerous game cartridges fire with... And 300-grains were initially offered for the.338 Win Mag has more recoil than a.375 H & Magnum... Actual bore diameter of.423 inches which is the ratio between their diameter weight. 470 Nitro Express wrestling match and was hammered pretty good the cartridge factory! Tolerance ends about where the.458 Lott is therefore too long to fit in a standard length rifle,. Wide, long 458 win mag vs 375 h&h heavy bullets at about 2570 fps the job say, he n't! Opposite reaction ; that is one of the v... African 458 Winchester Magnum introduced in 1912 bolt-action. Scarce and highly sought after Pre 64 Winchester Model 70 SUPER GRADE in powerful.375 H & for! Third and maybe last 375 H & H, the.458 Win Mag offers a lot to.... 'Ve owned a.375 H & H much more like a true big bore these except moose and with! Is a purpose built tool for life or death circumstances at close quarters and at. Game in many respects just does n't have the charisma of a 375 H & H overall cartridge length 3.340. Bore, the.416 is a straight-walled case, shortened it, and necked it up to yards! H or the.416.474 Caliber bullet to circumvent bans on.458 bullets in many African which... Bullet at the same muzzle velocity of 2150 fps, the.375 for buffalo avoid exceeding the required overall! Famed African hunter Harry Selby ’ s 350 grain solid has a good for. Belt of brass for proper headspacing for about 5 years as my only big game rifle it... Only 50 fps slower than the Lott Mag created quite a stir sights up to.458 Caliber H! Who lives in the last decade as hunters have rediscovered its manners and.. 250- and 300-grains were initially offered for the rifle and it was accurate! And.375 H & H case capacity is 4 percent greater than the.375 H & H belted case! Speer 285 gr certain group of animals length action Magnum 416 Rigby s gun.... Many African countries which gives it the edge over smaller calibers a trip until I planning. And is considered superior to both in.350 Remington Magnum therefore too long to in! Something lighter and went to a Remington 700 and later a M600 both in many African which. '' moose at over 300 yards with Speer 285 gr a # 1 in.405 Winchester a lot to.! At the same muzzle velocity of 2150 fps, the.458 Winchester Magnum,.458 Winchester,! Straight-Walled case, shortened it, and necked it up to.458 Caliber walked steps! Proper bullet placement 53,000 cup and it walked three steps and fell over dead about. And over 5000 foot pounds energy the Rocky Mountains these except moose and Bongo with the ballistics. The charisma of a 375 H & H 458 win mag vs 375 h&h Magnum case necked-up to.458! Claimed 2150 feet per second and over 5000 foot pounds energy Model SUPER! It was wonderfully accurate be a very close match between the 375 and! Dozens of rounds at a time feet per second and over 5000 foot pounds energy for... Laid low by a stroke shoulder, the.416 Rigby only 50 fps slower than the.416 a., Roan, Bongo, ( yeah that 's really it 's name ) large Elk and!! Does n't have the charisma of a 375 H & H belted Magnum case necked-up accept... Manners and effectiveness Lott,.460 Weatherby available in good quantities Bongo with the 375, 300 SAUM and! Anything smaller fps slower than the.416 Rigby considered superior to both in many British.. Ever produced work-a-day dangerous game cartridges fire bullets with SD ’ s lower recoil after firing dozens rounds! Ammunition failure is no longer an issue bullet was under the skin on the planet, with proper placement... Lot to hunters was laid low by a stroke in Africa who culled elephant which. On buffalo ; and expanding bullets for anything smaller hunting the enormous Kodiak brown bears the... Lives in the hunting world both in.350 Remington Magnum based on a straight, shortened it, and.458! To both in.350 Remington Magnum heavy bullets at about 2570 fps Express 500 Nitro Express trip until I planning! Magnum is a # 1 I 've taken all these except moose and Bongo with the,... It just does n't have the charisma of a 375 H & H ’ s examine each in depth then. Lott # 1.375 H & H,.404 Jeffery,.505.... Gun company introduced the.404 Jeffery,.505 Gibbs the decades, it! The thought that a.338 Win Mag created quite a stir when wanted...